State Farm® Insurance Agent Jay Carnahan

"Kennedy at the Carnahan agency was exceptional! After being a GEICO customer for over 10 years and facing continuous premium increases, I decided to shop around. The Carnahan Agency found me the best coverage at the best price compared to other State Farm agencies and all the other insurance companies I received quotes from in the Salt Lake Valley (Among the quotes I received for my vehicle, most were $160-170 a month—even higher than my current policy with Geico, I was very confused). I saved $34 monthly (~22% of my current premium) AND reduced my deductible from $1,000 to $500. What impressed me most was the Agency's professional approach - I had initially gotten a quote from Kennedy over a year ago, and they never pestered me with a barrage of emails or texts like other agencies often do (although for someone an occasional check-in can be a good thing, I'm very forgetful) When I finally decided to get my act together and call the Carnahan Agency back and get an updated quote, my quote had only increased modestly from $109 (in April/May 2025) to $118 (March 2025), which is reasonable given current market conditions and inflation. Meanwhile, my GEICO premium had jumped well over 10% the past year to $152 monthly, with further increases coming in a few weeks (I was getting quotes knowing my policy would expire 4/16). Making the switch to the Carnahan Agency was definitely the right choice! We're all feeling the pressure of inflation and rising prices these days. If you haven't gotten a quote on your auto/home/renters insurance in the past few months, I'd highly suggest get in touch with the Carnahan Agency. You could easily save over 20%/$300 a year like I did."

"I have been a client of Jay Carnahan’s office for a while for my renter’s insurance. They always respond fast and are super helpful. Recently, my parents in law who only speak Spanish also needed renter’s insurance, and Jake, who speaks Spanish, was able to help me out and give them a call and get my parents in law all set up. I really appreciate them, and especially Jake for his Spanish skills👌🏼"

"Jay's team was great"

"My family has been with Jay Carnahan's State Farm Insurance Agency for over a year. We have had great experience over all, but especially as of lately when we were getting prices quotes to add a teen driver to our policy. Mitzi helped us, she was quick and helpful in getting us an updated quote. To make it better, their quote was also almost half the price for my teen than the other companies. I definitely recommend!"

"Have worked with Mitzi at Jay Carnahan and she always does a great job. Thorough, helpful and very friendly! Would definitely recommend!"

"We've always had fast, friendly service with Jay's team. I've been so happy with the way we've been treated."

"Jay Carnahan listens, asks the right questions and supplies accurate answers to ensure your coverage is complete in a way that you are truly prepared and protected."

"Kennedy is great, she’s super professional. Would definitely recommend her"

"Jay is a very personable agent who takes a personal interest in taking care of his clients. I was very impressed."

"Working with Kennedy has been wonderful. She has made changing insurance so easy. Thank you so much for your excellent service."

"Kennedy was very helpful in getting a new home and auto policy setup for me."

"I got the pleasure of working with Kennedy when I called to get a quote on auto insurance. She was very helpful and knowledge and able to help me get better coverage with our house and auto insurance. I appreciate everything she did for me!"

"The Carnahan team has gone way above the call of duty for me for many years now. Jay really cares about his clients and always goes the extra mile to fulfill my needs!!"

"I wish all agents would work as fast and efficient as in thus location.. Kennedy, you're amazing.."

"Experienced agent. No sales pressure. very thorough. Easy to work with."

"Jay and crew are always so helpful! We highly recommend their services for home, car and life insurance. They take time to answer questions and really look for ways to save you money while still providing great coverage!"

"Love working with everyone in this office. Great response times on anything I ask for."

"I feel like State farm offers good insurance and fair enough rates. The real value is this office staff. They are second to none."

"Every time I call or talk to Jay or his team they are very helpful and knowledgeable. I would want any other team handling my vehicle or life insurances. They also have the best rates around."

"Jake was ready to update my policies to a higher deductible (to reduce premium monthly. Just received plumber bill for $4500. I panicked. Savings would be $30/mo. After all the work he did I changed my mind. And he reacted with something like no worries I’m here for you. Kind and professional from beginning to end. Thank you."

"Thanks for helping us with our insurance."

"Best insurance office ever"

"Amazing customer experience! I really appreciate Kennedy, she was extremely helpful and was able to get me the policy that was best for me."

"It is great to meet with Jay yearly to review our policies and make changes if needed.. Jay and his staff have always been so helpful ."

"10/10!!"